When it’s time for a new roof, many homeowners ask the same question: Should I replace gutters and my roof at the same time? The short answer? In many cases, yes. While gutters and roofs serve different functions, they work together as a complete system to protect your home from water damage, rot, mold, and more.
In this blog, we’ll break down why it often makes sense to replace your roof and gutters together when it’s not necessary, and what to expect if you do decide to tackle both at once.
Why Your Roof and Gutters Work as a Team
Your roof sheds water, and your gutters catch that water and direct it safely away from your foundation. If either system isn’t working properly, it puts your home at risk.
For example:
- A damaged roof can leak water directly behind the gutters.
- Warped or sagging gutters can cause water to pool on your roof edges, weakening shingles and decking.
- Missing flashing or poor alignment can make both systems fail together.
When one system needs work, the other is often affected too.
Top Reasons to Replace Gutters and Roof at the Same Time
Here are the most common reasons homeowners choose to replace gutters and the roof in one project.
1. Protect Your Investment
If your gutters are old, bent, or leaking, they can damage your brand-new roof by letting water pool where it shouldn’t. Likewise, installing a new gutter system onto an aging or compromised roof could be a waste if the roof fails soon after.
Replacing both at the same time ensures everything works properly and your investment lasts longer.
2. Save on Labor Costs
Combining the two projects can save money on labor, scaffolding, cleanup, and other shared job site expenses. Roofers already working on your home can coordinate the timeline so everything flows smoothly, minimizing return trips and project delays.
3. Avoid Potential Damage
Roofers need full access to your roofline during a replacement. This includes nailing shingles, adjusting flashing, and possibly replacing fascia boards. If old gutters are in the way, they may get damaged or removed during the process anyway.
Installing new gutters afterward ensures nothing was bent or shifted during roofing work.
4. Better Visual Match
Your roof and gutters are two of the most visible parts of your home. If you’re upgrading to a modern metal roof or designer asphalt shingles, pairing that with old, faded gutters can hurt your curb appeal.
Upgrading both ensures a fresh, uniform look that adds real value to your home.
When It’s Okay Not to Replace Gutters
That said, not every home needs to replace the gutter and roof at the same time.
Here are a few situations when it may be fine to replace only the roof (for now):
- Your gutters were installed recently (within the last 5–8 years)
- There are no leaks, rust, or sagging
- You have a seamless gutter system in excellent condition
- You’re on a tight budget, and the gutters are performing well
If your roofer determines that your gutters are in good shape, they’ll likely protect them during roof work and reinstall them afterward.
Signs It’s Time to Replace Your Gutters
If you’re not sure whether to include your gutters in the replacement project, watch for these warning signs:
- Cracks, holes, or rust spots
- Water stains on siding or foundation
- Pooling water or erosion near your home
- Sagging, detached, or overflowing gutters
- Repeated clogs or leaks, even after cleaning
If you’re seeing any of these, it’s a good time to plan for new gutters, especially when getting a new roof.
Homer Roofing: One Contractor for Both Roof and Gutters
At Homer Roofing, we believe in making home upgrades simple and stress-free. That’s why we offer both roofing and gutter installation services in-house, so you don’t have to juggle multiple companies, schedules, or warranties.
When we replace your roof, we can inspect your gutters at the same time and let you know if replacement makes sense. If your gutters are still in great shape, we’ll protect and preserve them. If not, we’ll help you pick a gutter system that complements your new roof and keeps your home protected for decades to come.
FAQs: Roof and Gutter Replacement in Ogden
Can I replace the gutters before my roof?
You can, but it’s not ideal. New gutters may get removed or damaged during a roof replacement. It’s best to wait and install new gutters after your new roof is complete.
How long does it take to replace both?
Most roof and gutter projects can be completed in 2–5 days, depending on your home’s size and weather conditions.
Will my new roof damage the existing gutters?
Our team uses protective measures to avoid gutter damage, but older or loosely secured gutters are always at higher risk.
Replace Gutters and Roof With One Call
Whether your gutters are barely holding on or just don’t match your beautiful new roof, combining both upgrades is often the smartest move. At Homer Roofing, we’ll walk you through every option and make sure your home gets the best care possible, top to bottom.
Schedule your free roof and gutter inspection in Ogden today and take the first step toward a safer, more stylish home.
