Free Quiz — Takes ~2 Minutes

Is Your Roofing Estimate Covering All the Bases?

You've got an estimate in hand. This quiz helps you evaluate whether it's thorough and professional — or if important details are missing.

Start the Quiz Get a Free Estimate to Compare

You've gathered a roofing estimate. Maybe two or three of them. The prices are different — sometimes wildly different — and you're not sure which one to trust. You're not alone. Most homeowners have no way to know whether an estimate is thorough and honest, or whether important line items are missing.

A professional roofing estimate should clearly detail the materials being used, the scope of work, what warranties you're getting, whether there will be project supervision and a final inspection, and any potential additional costs. If those details aren't there, you could be signing up for surprise charges, skipped steps, or warranty problems down the road.

This quiz walks through the key elements of a quality roofing estimate. Answer based on the estimate you're evaluating. At the end, you'll know whether it covers the essentials or whether you should be asking some hard questions before signing anything.

Question 1 of 9

Did the roofer physically get on your roof to inspect it before writing the estimate?

A contractor who writes a quote from the ground or from satellite images alone is guessing. Decking condition, flashing, and complexity require an up-close inspection.

Prefer to talk to someone? Call us directly.

Logan: (435) 787-0910 | Woods Cross: (801) 797-0418

What to Look For in a Roofing Estimate

A good roofer educates you

The best roofing contractors make sure you understand what's happening on your roof and why. If you feel like you're being sold rather than informed, that's a signal worth paying attention to.

Warranties should be explained in detail

You should understand the difference between the manufacturer warranty on the shingles and the contractor's workmanship warranty. These are two separate coverages, and both matter.

Ask about exclusions upfront

Things like rotten decking, extra shingle layers, skylight replacement, and difficult roof access can all add cost. A professional contractor flags these possibilities before you sign — not after.

Supervision and inspection matter

A project superintendent and a final inspection are signs of a professional operation. If nobody is checking the crew's work, quality control is left to chance.

Learn More

Cost & Pricing

Why Do Roofing Quotes Vary So Much?

How to Choose a Roofing Contractor: Red Flags & Questions

Roofing Materials Guide: Asphalt vs Metal vs Tile

Common Questions About Roofing Estimates

Why do roofing estimates vary so much from company to company? +

Materials, labor quality, what's included or excluded, warranty level, overhead, and profit margins all differ between contractors. A $6,000 estimate and a $14,000 estimate for the same roof are usually not quoting the same job.

What should a professional roofing estimate include? +

At minimum: specific material names and quantities, tear-off and disposal, underlayment and ice/water shield, flashing, pipe boots, ventilation, cleanup with nail sweep, and warranty details covering both manufacturer and workmanship coverage.

Is the cheapest roofing estimate always a bad sign? +

Not always, but usually. The most common reason for a low estimate is that something is being left out — whether that's quality materials, proper cleanup, warranty coverage, or all three. Compare line items, not just bottom lines.

Should I get more than one roofing estimate? +

Yes, always get at least 2–3 estimates. But don't just compare bottom-line prices. Compare what's included, what warranties are offered, and whether the contractor actually inspected your roof in person.

What's the biggest red flag in a roofing estimate? +

Vagueness. If the estimate says "roofing materials" instead of naming a specific product, or "labor" as a single lump sum with no detail, the contractor is either cutting corners or leaving room to surprise you later.

Want to Compare Your Estimate?

We provide detailed written estimates with specific product names, warranty tiers, and itemized costs. No vague line items. No surprises on install day.

Get a Free Inspection and Estimate Get Instant Estimate

Or call us: (435) 787-0910

Is Your Roofing Estimate Covering All the Bases?

Did the roofer physically get on your roof to inspect it before writing the estimate?

Did you receive a written estimate with itemized line items?

Did your roofer clearly explain the different warranties available (manufacturer's warranty, workmanship warranty, and wind coverage) and which one might be best for you?

Do you know exactly what work will be performed — including materials, shingle type, underlayment, and whether items like pipe boots, flashing, and ridge vents will be replaced?

Does the estimate include full tear-off and disposal of the old roof?

Did your roofer tell you if a supervisor will oversee the project and if a final inspection will be done once the roof is complete?

Do you feel everything was explained thoroughly (the good and the bad), or do you feel like you were being "sold" a roof?

Did your roofer go over potential exclusions or extra costs (such as skylight replacement, gutter cover removal, extra shingle layers, or rotten decking)?

Did the roofer show you proof of licensing and insurance?