Quick Answer

Before you hire a roofer, ask these five questions during the inspection: Can I see photos of what you found? Does my roof need a repair, a replacement, or nothing at all? What is in the price, and what could change it? Who will be on my roof, and are they licensed and insured? Who fixes it if something goes wrong years from now? A good roofer answers all five clearly, in writing, without pushing you to sign that day.

Here is the question we hear before almost every inspection: “What should I be asking you?”

It is a smart thing to wonder. Most homeowners buy a roof once or twice in their life. The person standing in your driveway has done this hundreds of times. That gap makes it easy to nod along and sign something you do not fully understand.

So here are the five questions we would ask if we were in your shoes. Ask them of us. Ask them of every roofer you talk to. The answers will tell you more than any sales pitch.

Keep this page open on your phone during the inspection if it helps. That is what it is for.

1. Can you show me photos of everything you found?

A roofer who inspects your roof should be able to show you every problem they found, in photos, before they talk about price.

You probably will not climb up there yourself, and you should not have to. Photos are how you see what they saw. Good photos are close enough to show the damage and wide enough to show where it is on your house.

A good answer sounds like: “Yes. Here is the hail bruising on the south slope, here is the cracked pipe boot over the bathroom, and here is the rest of the roof, which looks fine.”

Walk away if: they say the roof “needs to be replaced” but cannot show you why. Be careful, too, if the inspection was done only from the ground or a ladder at the gutter line. Our guide on what a roof inspection should include walks through the full checklist.

2. Does my roof need a repair, a replacement, or nothing at all?

An honest inspection ends with one of three answers: your roof is fine, it needs a repair, or it needs to be replaced. Ask which one, and ask why.

“Why” is the important part. A good roofer can explain the answer in plain words. Your shingles are losing granules and the mat is cracking. Or the roof is sound and the leak is one failed piece of flashing. Or there is nothing wrong at all.

A good answer sounds like: “You have a lot of life left in this roof. Fix this flashing and you should be good for years.”

Walk away if: every answer leads to a full replacement no matter what they see. Roofers make more money on replacements, so it takes some honesty to tell you a repair will do. Most roof repairs we do run $300 to $1,500. If you want to understand the difference yourself, read the signs your roof needs repair or replacement.

3. What is in the price, and what could change it after work starts?

Every roofing estimate should list what is included and name anything that could raise the price once the old roof comes off.

The biggest unknown on most jobs is the roof decking, the wood boards under your shingles. Rotted or soft decking cannot always be seen until tear-off. That is normal. What matters is whether the roofer tells you up front how they handle it and what it costs.

Here is how we handle it. Decking replacement is $85 per sheet installed (may fluctuate slightly with lumber prices), and the first 2 sheets are free on every job. Any extra sheets are photographed and reviewed with you before they go on the bill. Our decking guide has the details.

A good answer sounds like: “Here is the written scope. It lists the tear-off, the underlayment, the flashing, the vents, and the shingle line. The only thing that could change is decking, and here is exactly what that costs.”

Walk away if: the estimate is one line with one number on it, or the answer to “what could change?” is “we’ll see.” For a sense of what a fair price looks like in Utah, our pricing page lists real ranges. Most asphalt shingle replacements run $8,500 to $18,000.

4. Who will actually be on my roof, and are they licensed and insured?

You have a right to know who is working on your home and whether they are covered if someone gets hurt.

Some roofing companies use their own crews. Many also use subcontractor crews, especially in busy seasons. Neither is automatically bad. What matters is whether the roofer holds every crew to the same standard, or hands the job to whoever is free that week.

Ask for three things:

  • The contractor license number. Look it up on the Utah Division of Professional Licensing (DOPL) website. Ours is 1092697.
  • Proof of insurance. That means general liability and workers’ compensation. If a worker without coverage gets hurt on your property, it can turn into your problem.
  • Who the crew is. Ask if they are employees or subcontractors. If they use subcontractors, ask how those crews are trained and whether they are licensed and insured too.

A good answer sounds like: “Here is our license number and our insurance certificate. We use our own crew and subcontractor crews, and every one of them is trained and certified with GAF, licensed, and insured.”

Walk away if: they get vague, change the subject, or cannot give you a license number on the spot.

5. If something goes wrong in five years, who fixes it?

The answer should name two warranties: the manufacturer’s warranty on the materials and the roofer’s own workmanship warranty on the installation.

Most roof problems come from how the roof was put on, not from bad shingles. That makes the workmanship warranty the one that matters most. And a workmanship warranty is only as good as the company behind it. A lifetime promise from a roofer who rolled into town after a hailstorm may not be worth much in five years.

Ask how long they have been in business here, and where their office is. Ask what the warranty covers and get it in writing.

A good answer sounds like: “You get the GAF manufacturer warranty on the materials and our workmanship warranty on the install. We have been here since 2003, and our office is down the road.”

Homer Roofing gives a lifetime workmanship warranty on every job, and we have been answering the phone in Utah for over 20 years. One customer, Colton Goodrich, put it this way: “I had Homer Roofing complete a roof for me in 2019. Every shingle is fastened and secured. No issues.”

Walk away if: the warranty is verbal only, or they cannot tell you clearly what is covered. Our article on what a “lifetime” roofing warranty really means explains the fine print.

Is there a question you should not have to ask?

Yes: “Do I have to decide today?” You should never have to ask it, because a good roofer will not push you.

A real estimate is good for long enough to compare it with other bids and talk it over at home. If a roofer says the price is only good today, or that a “crew is already in the neighborhood” so you need to sign now, that is a sales tactic. We wrote more about this in our article on high-pressure roofing sales tactics in Utah.

What if you want to go deeper?

These five questions cover what matters most during the inspection. If you are comparing several bids and want a longer list, our guide on how to choose a roofing contractor in Northern Utah has 10 questions and a full list of red flags.

And if your roof was damaged in a storm and you are thinking about an insurance claim, ask the roofer how they help with that process. Our insurance claim help page explains what we do: we come to the adjuster meeting, bring documentation, and walk you through each step.

Key Takeaways

  • Ask to see photos of every problem before you talk about price.
  • Ask whether the roof needs a repair, a replacement, or nothing, and ask why.
  • Get a written scope, and ask what could change the price after tear-off.
  • Get the license number, proof of insurance, and who will be on the crew.
  • Ask who fixes problems years from now. The workmanship warranty and the company behind it matter most.
  • You never have to sign the same day. A good roofer will not ask you to.

FAQ

What should I ask a roofer during a roof inspection?

Ask five things: Can I see photos of what you found? Does my roof need a repair, a replacement, or nothing? What is in the price and what could change it? Who will do the work and are they licensed and insured? Who fixes it if something goes wrong years from now?

Should a roofer show me photos after an inspection?

Yes. A roofer who inspects your roof should show you photos of every problem they found, up close and with enough context that you can tell where it is on your house. If they cannot show you the damage, you have no way to know it is there.

How do I check if a roofer is licensed in Utah?

Ask for the roofer’s contractor license number, then look it up on the Utah Division of Professional Licensing (DOPL) website. Homer Roofing’s Utah contractor license number is 1092697.

What can change the price of a roof replacement after work starts?

The most common change is rotted roof decking, which cannot be seen until the old shingles come off. Homer Roofing charges $85 per sheet installed (may fluctuate slightly with lumber prices), includes the first 2 sheets free on every job, and photographs any extra sheets before they are added.

What is the difference between a manufacturer warranty and a workmanship warranty?

A manufacturer warranty covers defects in the roofing materials, and a workmanship warranty covers mistakes in how the roof was installed. Most roof failures come from installation, so the workmanship warranty, and whether the company will still be around to honor it, matters a lot.

Should I sign a roofing contract the same day as the inspection?

You do not have to, and a good roofer will not push you to. Take the written estimate, compare it to other bids, and decide when you are ready. A price that is only good today is a sales tactic, not a deal.

Bring These Questions to Your Inspection

Schedule a free roof inspection and ask us all five. We will show you the photos, tell you what your roof actually needs, and give you a written estimate with time to decide.

Or call us: (801) 797-0418